skip to main content
Nearly 4 in 10 Republicans Would Not Find McCain an "Acceptable" Nominee

Nearly 4 in 10 Republicans Would Not Find McCain an "Acceptable" Nominee

Clinton, Gore, Edwards most acceptable possible Democratic nominees

GALLUP NEWS SERVICE

PRINCETON, NJ -- A recent Gallup Panel poll asked Republicans and Democrats whether they would find each of several possible contenders for their party's 2008 presidential nomination to be "acceptable" nominees. Unlike other nomination ballot questions that measure respondents' first choice from among a list of possible candidates, this question paints a broader picture of the level of potential support and opposition for each candidate.

Hillary Clinton is the clear front-runner among Democrats when voters are asked to choose which one candidate they would prefer for the Democratic nomination for president, but the current poll finds Democrats are about equally likely to rate Clinton, Al Gore, and John Edwards as acceptable nominees. Rudy Giuliani and Sen. John McCain typically vie for the lead in Republican preference polls, but a greater percentage of Republicans say they would find Giuliani acceptable than say this about McCain (71% to 57%). Nearly 4 in 10 Republicans say they would not find McCain to be an acceptable GOP presidential nominee. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice is also widely considered by Republicans to be an acceptable nominee.

Gallup's June 26-29 poll tested Democrats' (and Democrat-leaning independents') reactions to 13 potential candidates and Republicans' (and Republican leaning independents') reactions to 12 potential candidates. While none of the politicians evaluated in the poll have officially announced their candidacies for president, many have laid the groundwork for a run by visiting early primary and caucus states like Iowa or New Hampshire or by setting up political action committees to raise money for themselves and other candidates. Others have been talked about as potential candidates, even though some (like Rice and Florida Gov. Jeb Bush) have stated they do not intend to run.

In general, very few of either party's candidates are rated acceptable by a majority of the party rank-and-file. For some candidates, this is because they are not yet well known and many respondents cannot evaluate them. At the same time, there are several other potential candidates who are better known but are already rated as "unacceptable" by a majority of their party.

While this approach gives a good sense of where the candidates currently stand, it is important to emphasize that these opinions can change once candidacies are officially announced and campaigning begins in earnest. Even if candidates are found "unacceptable" by a majority of their party's supporters now, that doesn't mean their candidacies are necessarily doomed. What it does indicate is that they are obviously starting off in a relatively weak position.

Republicans

Only three candidates would be acceptable to a majority of Republicans -- Giuliani (71%), Rice (70%), and McCain (57%).

Next, I'm going to read you a list of people who may run for the Republican nomination for president in 2008. For each, please tell me if you would find that person to be an acceptable nominee for president from the Republican Party, or not. First, [RANDOM ORDER].

BASED ON 441 REPUBLICANS OR REPUBLICAN LEANERS

2006 Jun 26-29

Yes,
acceptable

No,
not acceptable

No
opinion

%

%

%

Former New York City Mayor, Rudy Giuliani

71

24

5

Secretary of State, Condoleezza Rice

70

27

4

Arizona Senator, John McCain

57

36

6

Florida Governor, Jeb Bush

44

48

9

Former Speaker of the House, Newt Gingrich

43

51

7

Tennessee Senator, Bill Frist

37

39

24

Vice President, Dick Cheney

36

59

5

Virginia Senator, George Allen

32

35

34

New York Governor, George Pataki

32

49

19

Massachusetts Governor, Mitt Romney

26

42

32

Kansas Senator, Sam Brownback

18

39

43

Arkansas Governor, Mike Huckabee

17

40

43

Republicans are closely divided in their evaluations of Bush, Sen. Bill Frist, and Sen. George Allen as presidential nominee material. They tilt against the candidacy of Newt Gingrich, and appear to reject possible runs by Dick Cheney, Gov. George Pataki, Gov. Mitt Romney, Gov. Mike Huckabee, and Sen. Sam Brownback. Of this second tier of candidates, Huckabee, Brownback, Allen, and Romney are the least well known, so evaluations of them are probably most subject to change between now and the primary season.

So far, Bush and Cheney have indicated they will not run for president in 2008. Gingrich has not ruled out a bid, while Pataki, Frist, Romney, Huckabee, and Brownback are believed to be seriously considering a run and many have already made appearances in early primary and caucus states.

What is most notable in the Republican data is the substantial proportion of party supporters (36%) who would consider McCain an unacceptable nominee for their party. In polls measuring nomination preference, McCain usually places first or second to Giuliani. In early June, the last time Gallup measured nomination preferences, 28% of Republicans said they were most likely to support Giuliani and 24% McCain for the 2008 Republican presidential nomination.

The current poll's sample size of 441 Republicans and leaners limits the amount of subgroup analysis available, but the data show that conservative Republicans are less likely to deem McCain acceptable (54%) than Republicans who identify themselves as moderates or liberals (65%). Since nearly two Republicans identify themselves as politically conservative for every one saying they are liberal or moderate, McCain's challenge is clear. It is thus no surprise that he has recently made outreach attempts to conservative leaders, such as Jerry Falwell.

McCain's strength as a presidential candidate would be in his cross-party appeal if he were able to secure the Republican nomination. Independents (55%) and Democrats (56%) are about as likely as Republicans (59%) to view McCain favorably, according to a June 23-25 USA Today/Gallup poll. (Typically, partisan politicians receive much higher ratings from their party's supporters.)

Thus, McCain could be a very formidable candidate in the general election, but may have difficulty winning the Republican nomination. In 2000, he did quite well in primary states that allowed independents to vote in the Republican primary -- like New Hampshire and Michigan -- but did not fare as well in primaries where only registered Republicans could participate, such as Georgia, Florida, and Ohio. He also fared better in northeastern states where Republicans tend to be more moderate or liberal compared with Republicans in other parts of the country.

This suggests that at this early stage of the campaign, despite their close standings in preference polls, Giuliani has an advantage over McCain in that he more widely appeals to Republicans. Much can change once active campaigning begins, should both men decide to run. In particular, Giuliani's past support for abortion rights and gay rights could cause conservatives to sour on him. Rice would also appear be a formidable candidate but does not appear to be seriously considering a run for the presidency at this time.

Democrats

Most Democratic preference polls show Clinton with a wide lead over the rest of the potential Democratic field. Gallup's last test of Democrats' nomination preferences in June showed 37% supporting Clinton, compared with 16% for Gore, 12% for Edwards, and 11% for Sen. John Kerry. But the current analysis suggests that Democrats would be as likely to support Edwards or Gore as the nominee as they would Clinton, which suggests her early lead may not be insurmountable if her possible campaign struggles. Democrats would apparently be less enthusiastic about Kerry being nominated, who like McCain is acceptable to most members of his party but faces substantial opposition.

Next, I'm going to read you a list of people who may run for the Democratic nomination for president in 2008. For each, please tell me if you would find that person to be an acceptable nominee for president from the Democratic Party, or not. First, [RANDOM ORDER].

BASED ON 496 DEMOCRATS OR DEMOCRATIC LEANERS

2006 Jun 26-29

Yes,
acceptable

No,
not acceptable

No
opinion

%

%

%

New York Senator, Hillary Rodham Clinton

71

27

2

Former Vice President, Al Gore

70

29

2

Former North Carolina Senator, John Edwards

69

27

4

Massachusetts Senator, John Kerry

57

41

2

Democratic National Chairman, Howard Dean

44

50

7

Retired General, Wesley Clark

43

44

13

Delaware Senator, Joe Biden

39

40

21

New Mexico Governor, Bill Richardson

37

39

25

Former South Dakota Senator, Tom Daschle

34

50

16

Wisconsin Senator, Russ Feingold

29

43

29

Former Virginia Governor, Mark Warner

26

46

28

Ohio Congressman, Dennis Kucinich

22

52

27

Iowa Governor, Tom Vilsack

18

47

35

Democrats are evenly divided in their views of Sen. Joe Biden, Gov. Bill Richardson, and Wesley Clark as potential nominees. Clark is the best known of the three, perhaps due to his 2004 bid for the presidency.

There are three politicians who are found unacceptable by a majority of Democrats: Howard Dean, Rep. Dennis Kucinich (both of whom ran unsuccessfully in 2004), and Tom Daschle, the former Senate minority leader. Dean pledged not to run for president in 2008 while campaigning for his current position as chair of the Democratic National Committee.

Sen. Russ Feingold, former governor Mark Warner, and Gov. Tom Vilsack are thought to be seriously considering runs for the Democratic nomination, but all three are unknown to about one in three Democrats and are more likely to be viewed as unacceptable than acceptable nominees at this point.

Survey Methods

Results for this Gallup Panel study are based on telephone interviews with 496 Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents, aged 18 and older, and 441 Republicans and Republican-leaning independents, aged 18 and older, conducted June 26-29, 2006. Respondents were randomly drawn from Gallup's household panel, which was originally recruited through random selection methods. The panel was weighted prior to sampling so that it was demographically representative of the U.S. adult population. For results based on these samples, one can say with 95% confidence that the maximum margin of sampling error is ±5 percentage points. In addition to sampling error, question wording and practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of public opinion polls.

Next, I'm going to read a list of people who may be running in the Republican primary for president in the next election. After I read all the names, please tell me which of those candidates you would be most likely to support for the Republican nomination for President in the year 2008, or if you would support someone else. [ROTATED: Virginia Senator, George Allen; Kansas Senator, Sam Brownback; Tennessee Senator, Bill Frist; Former Speaker of the House, Newt Gingrich; Former New York City Mayor, Rudy Giuliani; Arkansas Governor, Mike Huckabee; Arizona Senator, John McCain; New York Governor, George Pataki; Massachusetts Governor, Mitt Romney]

BASED ON 419 REPUBLICANS AND REPUBLICAN LEANERS WHO ARE REGISTERED TO VOTE

BASED ON 449 REPUBLICANS AND REPUBLICAN LEANERS

2006 Jun 1-4

Republican
registered voters


All Republicans

%

%

Rudy Giuliani

29

28

John McCain

24

24

Newt Gingrich

8

8

Mitt Romney

6

7

Bill Frist

6

6

George Allen

5

5

Sam Brownback

2

2

Mike Huckabee

2

2

George Pataki

1

1

Other

3

3

None

4

4

All/any

1

1

No opinion

9

10

Next, I'm going to read a list of people who may be running in the Democratic primary for president in the next election. After I read all the names, please tell me which of those candidates you would be most likely to support for the Democratic nomination for President in the year 2008, or if you would support someone else. [ROTATED: Delaware Senator, Joe Biden; Retired General, Wesley Clark; New York Senator, Hillary Rodham Clinton; Former South Dakota Senator, Tom Daschle; Former North Carolina Senator, John Edwards; Wisconsin Senator, Russ Feingold; Former Vice President, Al Gore; Massachusetts Senator, John Kerry; Former Virginia Governor, Mark Warner; Iowa Governor, Tom Vilsack]

BASED ON 447 DEMOCRATS AND DEMOCRATIC LEANERS WHO ARE REGISTERED TO VOTE

BASED ON 489 DEMOCRATS AND DEMOCRATIC LEANERS

2006 Jun 1-4

Democratic
registered voters


All Democrats

%

%

Hillary Rodham Clinton

36

37

Al Gore

16

16

John Edwards

12

12

John Kerry

11

11

Wesley Clark

4

4

Joe Biden

4

4

Russ Feingold

3

3

Mark Warner

2

2

Tom Daschle

*

1

Tom Vilsack

--

--

Other

3

3

None

2

3

All/any

*

*

No opinion

5

5

* Less than 0.5%


Gallup https://news.gallup.com/poll/23764/Nearly-Republicans-Would-Find-McCain-Acceptable-Nominee.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030