skip to main content

Most NATO Members in Eastern Europe See It as Protection

Most NATO Members in Eastern Europe See It as Protection
by Michael Smith

Story Highlights

  • Majorities in Poland, Estonia and Lithuania see NATO as protection
  • 67% of Russians view NATO as a threat
  • 3% of Russians view NATO as protection

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- While U.S. President Donald Trump, even as recently as January, referred to NATO as "obsolete," residents in many NATO member countries in Eastern Europe associate the alliance with the protection of their countries. This includes majorities in Poland, Estonia and Lithuania, where NATO allies, including the U.S., have recently sent troops to quell security concerns after Russia's actions in Ukraine.

Eastern European Countries' Views of NATO in 2016
Do you associate NATO with protection of your country, as a threat to your country or do you see it as neither protection nor a threat?
Protection Threat Neither
% % %
Kosovo 90 3 6
Albania 70 3 22
Poland 62 8 22
Lithuania 57 13 25
Estonia 52 17 26
Croatia 52 17 19
Romania 50 8 25
Hungary 49 9 25
Latvia 49 16 29
Czech Republic 46 13 27
Macedonia 45 13 24
Slovakia 37 19 35
Bosnia and Herzegovina 28 21 38
Bulgaria 28 20 34
Greece 23 19 45
Montenegro 21 29 35
Serbia 6 64 19
Gallup

The U.S. is a founding member of NATO, but its commitment to the alliance has been questioned after Trump publicly raised doubts about NATO's relevance and its funding before he took office. However, according to NATO, Trump agreed on Sunday to attend a meeting of NATO leaders in May, and he and NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg "reconfirmed the importance of the alliance in troubled times." And on Monday, Trump reaffirmed his support for NATO on a visit to the headquarters of the U.S. Central Command.

How the U.S. interacts with NATO has far-reaching consequences overseas, because many Eastern European countries count on NATO for protection. Last October, the United Kingdom sent 800 troops to Estonia. And shortly before President Barack Obama left the White House, the U.S. sent 4,000 troops to Poland to protect it and neighboring NATO allies Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia from perceived aggression from neighboring Russia.

Attitudes Toward NATO in Eastern Europe, CIS

Kosovo, although not a NATO member, received military support from NATO during the Kosovo War between the former Yugoslavia and the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA), and its residents overwhelmingly (90%) look at the alliance as protection. The same holds true for residents of NATO member Albania (70%) -- which also supported the ethnic Albanian KLA during the war. Similarly, it is not surprising that 64% of Serbians in 2016 view NATO as a threat and 6% see it as protection.

Russia, Countries in Russia's Sphere of Influence See NATO as a Threat

With NATO's inclusion of several post-Soviet states after the dissolution of the Soviet Union, and its rebuking of Russia's involvement in Ukraine, it is no surprise that Russia is at odds with NATO. Sixty-seven percent of Russians in 2016 view NATO as a threat, which is up 29 percentage points since 2012, and is the highest number that Gallup has recorded since it started tracking Russians' views on NATO in 2008.

Trend: Russians' Views of NATO

Residents of countries in Russia's sphere of influence that are not NATO members tend to share Russia's views on the alliance, if they have an opinion. Fifty-four percent of Belarusians view NATO as a threat, a 19-point jump from four years ago. Along with the Russians and Belarusians, more people in Ukraine (35%), Kazakhstan (31%), Kyrgyzstan (30%), Moldova (27%), Armenia (20%) and Tajikistan (34%) view NATO as a threat than as protection.

Views of NATO in Post-Soviet States
Do you associate NATO with protection of your country, as a threat to your country or do you see it as neither protection nor a threat?
Protection Threat Neither
% % %
Belarus 3 54 30
Russia 3 67 20
Armenia 8 20 38
Tajikistan 8 34 20
Moldova 16 27 38
Kyrgyzstan 19 30 12
Azerbaijan 21 16 44
Kazakhstan 25 31 27
Ukraine 29 35 26
Georgia 37 8 35
Gallup World Poll, 2016

Ukrainians Sour on NATO

The proportion of residents of Ukraine -- a potential NATO member state until a few years ago -- who view NATO as a threat has increased in recent years after years of steady decline between 2008 and 2014. In 2014, after NATO sanctioned Russia after it annexed Crimea, Ukrainians for the first time were more likely to see NATO as protection (36%) than a threat (20%). However, the percentage viewing it as a threat shot back up to 35% in 2016 as the Ukrainian population has grown tired of the ongoing conflict between its military and Russian-backed separatists, as well as a poor economy and rising crime rates. Without a clear end in sight to the conflict, Ukrainians may be losing confidence in NATO's ability to help them in this crisis.

Trend: Ukrainians' Views of NATO

Implications

With Russia's recent military activity in the region, and with many Eastern European countries relying on the U.S. and NATO for protection, the United States' future commitment to NATO is at a critical point. If the U.S. were to leave NATO, Russia would stand to benefit because a NATO without the United States' full cooperation would be less equipped to curtail any Russian military and political expansion. It would also strain the United States' relationships with many European allies, potentially weakening important military and economic partnerships that are vital to the United States' foreign policy interests.

Survey Methods

Results are based on telephone interviews conducted throughout 2016 in the countries included in the analysis with a random sample of approximately 1,000 adults, aged 15 and older, living in each country. In Russia, the sample size was 2,000 adults. For results based on the total sample of national adults, the margin of sampling error ranges from ±2.7 percentage points to ±3.9 percentage points at the 95% confidence level. All reported margins of sampling error include computed design effects for weighting.

Gallup


Gallup http://www.gallup.com/poll/203819/nato-members-eastern-europe-protection.aspx
Gallup World Headquarters, 901 F Street, Washington, D.C., 20001, U.S.A
+1 202.715.3030